Plastic Writing
Originally published on Substack ·
I used AI to “write”. Well, I threw in something I spent a lot of time drafting. An article about the value of stock/shares in an offer, and what to be wary of when looking at startup jobs. I threw it into Claude and what came out was something plausible — tied up loose ends, organized, structured. But lacking the depth, emotion and personal anecdotes I had infused into my “shitty draft” that I hadn’t looked at in almost 2 years.
I used to be a writer as part of my marketing jobs. If you look me up, you’ll see my articles and my signature. I love em dashes and have been using them since I was a kid, back when I carried the Strunk + White in my bag. The Claude-generated “better” draft made me recoil. It was better by a mediocre writer’s standards — a formulaic approach-follower’s dream. Yet it abstracted the meaning, the craft of writing, and the “me-ness” out of the thing.
I was struggling to make a point (as I often do) via the draft, as the comments from my kind friends attest to, but the point Claude was making was neither mine nor in my voice. I used to say I’m a much better editor than writer (perhaps because I read a lot and critique a lot). But when Claude edited my LinkedIn post, I realized how much better mine was and how poorly it interpreted my instructions. But here I had better feeling about myself and it helped me quickly tweak what I had written, which was ultimately more than good enough.
The writing felt plastic–like a face injected and sliced, stapled–plausible but stilted.